The right to be forgotten is
the concept that individuals have the civil right to request that personal
information is removed from the Internet.
In May 2014, a man from Spain asked
Google to remove links to an old newspaper article about his previous
bankruptcy, claiming there was no legitimate reason for the outdated
information to remain accessible online. The European Court of Justice ruled
that under European law, search engines are data controllers so they must
consider all requests to stop returning irrelevant or outdated information in
search queries. According to the ruling, the Web pages that the query results
in question point to can remain online and any link omissions on query returns
will only occur when searches are made in Europe. In the wake of the ruling,
Google began receiving thousands of more requests to take down links.
While the right to be forgotten aims to
support personal privacy, the concern is that it conflicts with the open nature
of the Web and the free flow of information. The interests of one individual in
removing information from the Web may conflict with the interests of another
individual or group. While Google is not required to honor every request for
information to be taken down, it seems clear that the popularity of the concept
will inspire organizations to have a process in place for reviewing and
following through on take-down requests.
Currently, the General Data Protection Regulation ruling applies only in
the European Union, but according to some research, Americans might be
interested in a similar right in the U.S. in spite of concern from the
opposition that removal of legally published and truthful information from the
open Web infringes on First Amendment rights and smacks of censorship.
Comments
Post a Comment